###Update###
I tried a bit of Notesnook. While it wasnt bad it didnt quite fit the expectation that obsidian created for me for what I want. Maybe it was user error but I honestly can’t say what specific aspect bothered me.
For now I decided to stay with what I have experience witg and bought a year of Obsidian-sync for 1 Remote-Vault
Thanks to everyone that suggested me solutions to my really specific problem. I appreciate that and I love(d) the discouse I seemingly sparked in this post.
Please continue commenting. Maybe someone else still hasnt found their solution yet :)
Original Post:
Hello fellow lemmy users, for the lack of a better fitting community I hope my request for help fits here the best.
I am a bit of a scatter-brain, have some notes in Google Keep, OneNote, Obsidian and in GitHub or other places. This is partially multiplied by splitting my work stuff with my home stuff.
What I like about every app I use so far
- OneNote: I like the way I can write on something like a canvas. Very useful if the note does fit the general theme of the page but not at the exact position. Also helps by utilizing the big space of a horizontal monitor. Also it now sports a very good mobile editor.
- Obsidian: So easy to backlink between notes and I love the graph view. I also like the extension “code styler” which lets me format inline code blocks with syntax highlighting (e.g.: `{powershell icon} Get-ChildItem -Path C:\Path\To\Folder -Filter XYZ*`).
I like to learn scripting but I also use obsidian for RL-stuff and technical non-code like keeping track of configs, settings, wishlists etc. - Google Keep: I bastardize the check-box feature to keep track of (online) shop orders. Mostly the only reason is that checked items get hidden in a collapsed section
Any other program that let’s me to that (even with plugin/extension) is a valid replacement candidate
What I dislike:
- OneNote:
- Quite difficult to link between notes (unsupported on mobile)
- Limited to 1 folder deep notes. Currently work around that by using the horizontal space or multi notes.
- A bit clunky to edit bigger notes
- By microsoft.
- Obsidian:
- No native way to have everything on a server outside of using the obsidian-sync service for $4 or the community plugin which requires me to use some novel type of db called couch-db (ugh, another service to keep updated/troubleshoot). I can stomach the $4 but am limited to only one vault which I don’t really like.
- Google Keep:
- No real way to have everything backed up. Only use it for quick notes or for my shipment list. Everything else is probably exported to Obsidian/OneNote if I feel like doing house-keeping.
How I currently manage/store my files:
- Right now I use
- OneNote which is stored on OneDrive (I like how Outlook (classic) works and I got 1TB of cloud storage),
- Obsidian which syncs with the plugin “remotely sync” to my OneDrive folder.
- Google Keep: Dunno. Probably some account storage on google
What I want:
- A primarily server-side setup or with a native sync feature that works like on OneNote: The true source is my server or the cloud, the client only streams/caches the data locally. I have no problem with individual markdown files.
I just dislike the general need to sync them manually with external tools like syncthing.
I already have a good backup solution on my main server and secondary server (For the curious: Veeam backup and replication that backs my proxmox VMs). No need to manage another set of backups. Another reason I want everything in one spot as I already have everything scattered. - A tree view of my notes like obsidian and OneNote does. Plus point if the app can even do sections like OneNote does.
- (Optional) A way change-log of the edits done. Some apps do it by implementing git or have a very rudimentary way to manage that
- Mobile/desktop companian app: PWA is okay but I would probably miss out on the caching feature. I would prefer an actual (android) app on my phone. Same for Windows.
What I found so far but have issues so far:
- silverbullet: Server-side but seems to miss the side bar with the tree view (which can probably be added by another extension). Seems like the best candidate so far
- Joplin: Seems alright to use but I can’t use callouts which (to me) is mandatory to use with coding/scripting tasks.
- Obsidian: Fits best of all I found but I dislike the $4. But still miles better as the former option which was (i believe) $15 monthly
- BookStack: I bit limited how it manages the change-log. Seems okay
- Outline: No way to sync it without paying beyond manual sync. Didnt try it out much but I like how it looks.
- Logseq: Same issues as with obsidian: Paid sync. Didnt look much beyond
- Joplin: Sufficient but no callouts :(
- Trilium Notes: Maintenance mode. Not a deal-breaker but I don’t want to migrate something that could maybe die :/
Thanks for reading the wall of text and I wish you a good start into the year of 2025. ✌️
You must log in or # to comment.
Lol at the obsidian criticisms in the self hosted community :)
Couchdb is like 20 years old and not exactly ‘novel’
I setup a docker for his like 2 years ago and did nothing other than update once in that time. Live sync has otherwise been rock solid on multiple devices.
Obsidian not being open source is very valid criticism. The above 2 things really aren’t.
I actually only discovered silverbullet a few days ago, but liking it so far.
The TreeView plugin is documented here: https://silverbullet.md/Plugs/TreeView
So you dislike external sync options but also don’t want to pay for internal sync options? Additionally you are in a self hosted community so you’re looking for a presumably open source project (some you listed are not), and given internally supported sync services would be one way fund development i think this narrows what your are looking for by quite a bit. You basically would be looking for an open source project that meets all your other criteria and happens to let you sync the files to your own server for free. Why would such a project not just let you take things into your own hands with whatever flavor of sync/backup you prefer? Otherwise if they’re building a sync system it would probably be a monetized cloud service which brings us back to the beginning.
Maybe such a thing exists, but I haven’t seen such a thing since that is extra development for little to no gain. Most people are happy to either pay for the cloud service to fund development or sync on their own.
Logseq: Same issues as with obsidian: Paid sync. Didnt look much beyond
Logseq is open source. Obsidian is not. So yes, both have paid sync but you can also just sync or backup the files on your own. Just be careful of sync services that sync while files/db are in use to avoid conflicts.
Maybe it’s just how I conveyed the idea.
Basically something like obsidian (or any other KB solution with markdown) but it can also support self-hosted sync-servers preferably natively.
Obsidian has it to some degree with a community plugin (totally valid. I just dislike having to use an external DB rather than bare files).
The alternative is using a separate app/program like syncthing but then I’d have to keep both open and one continuously open. My preference would be an all-in-one edit and sync. This way the program would also be aware of the content sync and could close in the background once synced
I just use Joplin, encrypted, and synced through dropbox. Tried logseq, but never really figured out how to use its features effectively. The notebook/note model of Joplin seems more natural to me. My coding/scripting stuff mostly just goes into git repos.
Joplin: Sufficient but no callouts :(
Can you give an example of those “callouts”? Joplin has many plugins, many you can find that in there.
My only complaint about Joplin is that there’s no production / real WebUI for it yet.
I did search for plugins but couldnt find any. Maybe the wrong search term?
Regarding what they are: https://help.obsidian.md/Editing+and+formatting/Callouts
The fuck? How did I skim over that…
Literally read this post but stopped once I saw how OP wanted to do this in CSS.
Oh well…Well it happens :D Happy new year!
Just use obsidian with sync thing.
This.
Also, one of the machines is running the git plugin, so things get saved in my Forgejo as well. I guess I could set it up so they save to hit, but in different branches. 🤔
You are posting in self hosted by also referencing some software that isn’t so I’m not sure exactly what you’re asking for in that regard.
Saber is the only non-onenote notes software that supports handwriting and is fully FOSS, to my knowledge. I use that and then back up with Syncthing.
Hello fellow lemmy users, for the lack of a better fitting community I hope my request for help fits here the best.
And I am also mentioning self-hostable solutions like silverbullet. And there might be a program that nobody has listed yet but may fit all criteria.
Gotcha. I like Saber for handwritten notes. It also supports photos and PDFs, so I will get some meeting notes, upload them into Saber and then handwrite notes on top of the PDFs.
It is cross-platform and has native NextCloud support, and they’ll even give you a server to use if you sponsor the project.
I use Obsidian and pay for Sync. You are not limited to one vault, I have multiple vaults synced, don’t know where you got that information?
Can recommend doing this, vault is E2E encrypted and the people behind Obsidian seem decent. They are very much opposed to taking VC money and the growth at all cost mindset. See the blog of their CEO to get a vibe check: https://stephango.com/
I got my info from here: https://obsidian.md/buy/sync?variation=standard_10&renew=yearly
1 synced vault · 1 month history
But it seems like I can link multiple local vaults inside this remote vault? Sorta like subfolders
Still early in development, but I’m liking Affine. Self hostable, and the whiteboard tools are pretty great
I use Obsidian primarily and just push everything to git. Remember to gitignore
.obsidian/workspaces.jsonto prevent conflicts on multiple devices.Note for Obsidian, there is a git plugin that can auto-push/pull from a repo. I put my repo on a server and have multiple devices use it as a sync feature (there is also a VPN to my home network involved). Not sure how well it works on the android app (its pure lazyness as to why I haven’t tried that yet…)
As far as my research today yielded the implementation on Android is error-prone due to no native git integration.
As long as it’s less stable than using remotely-save + OneDrive it’s a pass :/
having a solid git integration that works without much fuzz (e.g. manually committing, annotating) would be lovely though.This seems very error-prone: https://www.reddit.com/r/ObsidianMD/comments/17odzjb/obsidian_android_syncing_via_github_in_2023/
And this seems very dangerous without a native full integration: https://github.com/Vinzent03/obsidian-git?tab=readme-ov-file#performance-on-mobile
I use Obsidian with a docker version of CouchDB. Used to store on Dropbox using Remotely Save.
community plugin which requires me to use some novel type of db called couch-db (ugh, another service to keep updated/troubleshoot).
I am fine with paying for obsidian-sync as I like the service and am experienced with their flavor of markdown. But before I cough up another money hole for a rarely (1-3 times per month) accessed program I’d prefer another (self-hosted) alternative and donate to the dev instead.
I also don’t like hosting what I don’t quite understand (that means mostly databases). I am already uneasy to host the mariaDB I have setup for hortusFox.I agree that I don’t like the sync stored in a db rather than a directory of files. I just reminded myself that Remotely Save also saves to webdav on my Synology NAS and to Nextcloud. Since I have both available, I will be looking at them again.
Just as an FYI its done like this because its vastly faster than flat files.
This is also the reason why NextCloud has lots of complaints about speed and files getting locked and not syncing properly.
Apps that are way faster (seafile, owncloud GO) use proprietary file stores.
Obsidian Live sync works extremely well and quickly to the point that the update speed is almost like a google docs with multiple editors. Couchdb is why.
I just use Obsidian + Syncthing + MEGA. My obsidian folders are on my mega synced folder on my pc, and they are set up to use syncthing to push updates to all my other devices (2 phones and a tablet), but you can have as many devices as you want. It’s all free as well, and the cloud service can be any that you like.
Keep in mind that the Syncthing Android app was discontinued and thus isnt viable long term. The team wont work anymore on it and once it breaks it’s done for.
I could use Resilio for that but meh…Syncthing-Fork ☞ https://f-droid.org/packages/com.github.catfriend1.syncthingandroid/
Yeah, I just use the fork.
ty :)
I like that the team promotes the fork.
Only the one written by the original Dev. There are others like syncthing fork.
Its still a perfectly viable solution for android.
Maybe Orgzly?
Am I blind or is it mobile only? Would probably create issues if I use 3rd party plugin features in other apps if I don’t stay markdown-only Also it seems like I have to manually sync the file?
You can sync it using e.g. webdav and use any app you want on another client
Has anyone suggested a Nextcloud installation? You’d have a notes sync as part of the whole calendar setup. I use QownNotes on my Linux computers and the native notes app on my de-googled Android phone. The phone requires the DavX app to setup the sync, but it’s bulletproof after that. The notes are available as .md files and exportable as pdf.
Nextcloud might seem like overkill, but it is light enough to run on a Pi4 and it would take care of most of your server management and update challenges. You can use as much or as little of its functions as you want.
I don’t think I have any use for something like Nextcloud.
The only one that uses my server is myself + the few friends accessing Jellyfin.
To me, some SMB shares are sufficient at home and on the go I only access my HortusFox and Jellyfin (+ *arrs) services.
Assuming I’d have to setup something for another family member as well like an SO, I’d probably have to setup something like Next/Owncloud
I think before I setup something like that, I’ll setup Immich first. Also on my todo list but the rapid dev release cycle clashes with my automated update schedule and would require active attention to the changelogs.
And according to the self.st newsletter there are plenty of breaking changes happening to immich.If you have a different experience with Immich and docker, please feel free to correct me. It would accelerate my deployment schedule and backup.
Okay. I only suggested it because it’s probably one of the best maintained and funded Open Source projects in the world and the caldav/carddav setup is almost automatic. It would allow you to use any caldav friendly notes app on phone or desktop, which means it’s Apple, Windoze or open source friendly.
Generally, I avoid obscure ‘solutions’ and stick to mature tech.
Anyway, good luck.
